The phrase “sophomore slump” exists for good reason, but Samsung’s second-generation Galaxy Buds bring a novel feature set to the table, making them a compelling buy for any Spotify user. That said, just because the Samsung Galaxy Buds Plus are newer doesn’t make them a better choice for everyone. Let’s see how the original Galaxy Buds compare to the new kid on the block, and why last year’s Buds may be the better option for some.

Editor’s note: this versus was updated on March 27, 2020, to address pricing in the FAQ section.

Hardware

A picture of the Samsung Galaxy Buds Plus and Galaxy Buds' true wireless charging cases open with the earbuds inside.

The Samsung Galaxy Buds and Galaxy Buds Plus appear nearly the same, and both are available on Amazon.

The Galaxy Buds Plus and Galaxy Buds are indistinguishable from one another; the new edition is available in black, white, and light blue while the original is available in black, white, yellow, and silver. The Buds Plus retains the same whimsical design as before which is both practical and fun. Everything from the plastic construction to the silicone wing and ear tips remains unchanged. Samsung includes three extra pairs of sleeves and tips with both models, so listeners are more likely to find a proper fit. This provision not only improves comfort but also optimizes audio quality by passively blocking out external noise.

Listeners should use the various ear tips to find a proper fit.

Users can remap the touch-capacitive panels on each headset, and sensitivity is the same between the old and new Galaxy Buds. Automatic ear detection remains present with the new Samsung Galaxy Buds Plus: removing both earbuds automatically pauses media playback. Just as before, re-inserting the Buds Plus does not resume playback; instead, you must manually hit play on your smartphone or tap an earbud to resume music.

Both the Samsung Galaxy Buds Plus and Samsung Galaxy Buds support Wireless PowerShare, which lets you charge the USB-C case wirelessly atop a compatible Samsung Galaxy smartphone. You can also use a Qi wireless charging mat to charge the case, affording you plenty of options for topping up the pill-shaped case.

A picture of the Samsung Galaxy Buds Plus and Galaxy Buds earphones without the ear tips on.

The Samsung Galaxy Buds Plus look nearly identical to the original but house a new dual-driver system for clear audio reproduction.

The only physical design amendments made to the Plus model are seen in the case: it now shines with a glossy, rather than matte, finish. Then there’s the silicone “L R” piece that does nothing more than indicate where to place the earbuds. I initially thought this was a functional button, but alas, it’s just an aesthetic change. Original Galaxy Buds owners who upgrade to the Samsung Galaxy Buds Plus can use either case to charge either pair of earbuds. In other words, you can plop the older earbuds into the Plus case to charge them, and vice versa.

Neither appearance nor build quality should be a critical factor when deciding between the Samsung Galaxy Buds and Galaxy Buds Plus model, and this one is too close to call.

Winner: Draw

Features

A picture of the Samsung Galaxy Buds Plus true wireless earbuds on top of a Samsung Galaxy S10e smartphone in flamingo pink.

You can charge the case via Wireless PowerShare or with a Qi-certified power mat.

One of the major selling points of the Plus headset is exclusive Spotify integration; Samsung is swaggering around dropping Spotify’s name like crazy, and for good reason: Spotify is among the most popular music streaming services worldwide.

See also:

Why I’m an avid Spotify user despite dubious audio quality

Seeing these two audio powerhouses team-up is a sight to behold, and one-touch access to Spotify is something I dearly miss upon returning to standard wireless headphones. By pressing and holding one of the earbuds (chosen in the Galaxy Wearable application), a recommended set of songs is queued up. This is randomly generated according to your preferences and ranges from one of Spotify’s Daily Mix playlists, an artist or song radio, genre playlist, and more. Unfortunately, this perk is only afforded to Android OS devices, so iPhone users still need to enter the Spotify app for music playback.

There are some similarities here, too, though as both pairs of earbuds earned an IPX2 rating, making them sweat-resistant. General consumers who want the option to workout with their daily earbuds will benefit from either headset’s durability. No matter which earbuds you go with, you have the option to enable ambient aware mode. This is great for outdoor runners and general consumers: it keeps you aware of your surroundings, thereby enabling you to stay safe or engage in conversation with the train ticketer.

The Galaxy Buds Plus ambient sound mode is limited to three modes: high, medium, and low. Yet, the older Galaxy Buds support a “voice focus” mode, which further amplifies vocal frequencies through the earphones. This is as of software version R175XXU0ATA6 for the Buds Plus; perhaps we’ll see an experimental addition in the “Labs” section of Samsung’s app, or even as a full-fledged feature with future updates.

Both headsets support software updates through the Samsung Galaxy Wearable app.

To my dismay, neither the Samsung Galaxy Buds Plus nor the Galaxy Buds support standard Bluetooth multipoint connectivity. Although the Galaxy Buds Plus promised this feature across Bluetooth 5.0 devices, the company has since removed any mention of multipoint support from the official website. When I asked a Samsung representative whether support would make its way to the Galaxy Buds Plus, she shared, “Multipoint connectivity is not available on the Galaxy Buds+ at this point.”

Due to Spotify integration, we’re giving this round to the Galaxy Buds Plus.

Winner: Samsung Galaxy Buds Plus

Battery life

A picture of the Samsung Galaxy Buds Plus and Galaxy Buds with one earbud in each case atop an illustrated book.

The original Galaxy Buds fit into and charge via the Buds Plus case.

This is the easiest metric to measure. We subjected each pair of earbuds to our standard battery test, a constant 75dB(SPL) output, and noted the results. The original Galaxy Buds last 6.53 hours while the Buds Plus last 11.73 hours under identical conditions. This is a remarkable leap in playtime, and each charging case provides an extra charge cycle, doubling total on-the-go playtime. This means you get under 24 hours of listening with the Samsung Galaxy Buds Plus, and just over 12 hours with the Galaxy Buds.

Both earbuds support fast charging: the Galaxy Buds supply 1.7 hours of playtime from 15 minutes in the case, and the Buds Plus supply one hour of listening after just three minutes in the case. Again, both USB-C cases support Wireless PowerShare and are Qi-compatible.

Winner: Samsung Galaxy Buds Plus

Bluetooth version/codecs

A picture of the Samsung Galaxy Buds Plus and Galaxy Buds on a black backpack.

Neither headset supports aptX.

The same Bluetooth codecs are supported by these Bluetooth 5.0 headsets: AAC and the Scalable Samsung codec. It’s a bummer that Samsung didn’t go in for aptX support, but makes sense to push its proprietary codec. The scalable codec operates similarly to aptX Adaptive because it’s always optimizing for the best bitrate without compromising connection strength. This is, however, only compatible with certain Samsung devices operating Android 7.0 and later.

Despite the same specs on paper, the Galaxy Buds Plus perform better with fewer connection stutters when taken outdoors, something the original Galaxy Buds still struggle with. When I worked on the Apple AirPods vs. Samsung Galaxy Buds article, there were a handful of times when I had to unpair and re-pair the Buds to my Galaxy S10e smartphone.

Winner: Samsung Galaxy Buds Plus

Microphone quality

Microphone quality is straightforward: Samsung improved the mic array in its latest true wireless earbuds, and it shows. The Samsung Galaxy Buds Plus three-microphone array sounds markedly better than the original Galaxy Buds’ system. The new model uses two external mics to focus on your voice while simultaneously reducing ambient noise, which is similar to how the AirPods Pro operate. The more neutral frequency response of the Buds Plus microphones means you’re less likely to sound “distant” or “unnatural.” Be sure to listen to our demos below to determine for yourself which is best.

Samsung Galaxy Buds Plus microphone demo:

Samsung Galaxy Buds microphone demo:

Winner: Samsung Galaxy Buds Plus

Sound quality and fit

It’s easy to forget that we’re looking at earbuds; after all, Samsung packs plenty of technology into both pairs of Galaxy Buds. When push comes to shove, though, we can’t forget the importance of sound quality. Both headsets are tuned by Samsung subsidiary AKG but the audio reproduction varies between the two models. You can choose between a few EQ presets including normal, soft, dynamic, clear, and treble boost with the Galaxy Buds. The Samsung Galaxy Buds Plus offers a bass boosts option, too, via the Samsung Wearable app.

A picture of the Samsung Galaxy Buds Plus and Galaxy Buds earphones without the ear tips on.

The Samsung Galaxy Buds Plus look nearly identical to the original but house a new dual-driver system for clear audio reproduction.

Listeners who want a more accurate, neutral-leaning frequency response straight from the box will prefer the first-generation Galaxy Buds, which are equipped with drivers that reproduce accurate low and midrange frequencies. There’s little deviation across the audible spectrum, making them an excellent choice for listeners with eclectic musical taste.

On the other hand, the Samsung Galaxy Buds Plus reproduce a more consumer-friendly sound with amplified bass notes and a slight emphasis to midrange harmonics. The former adds greater impact to bass lines and kick drums while the latter contributes to a perceived sense of improved clarity. We often ascribe auditory detail to our ability to register harmonic resonances, be it vocal ringing or the sound of calloused fingers sliding up a fretboard, and the 700Hz-2kHz bump does just that.

Although sound quality will come down to your personal preference, we’re giving this to the Buds Plus again for its inclusion of ear and wing tips which allow for optimal audio reproduction.

Winner: Draw

The Samsung Galaxy Buds Plus are the better earbuds, so why get the Galaxy Buds?

A picture of the Samsung Galaxy Buds earbuds in the case, which is open, with part of a Google Pixel 3 in the bottom left corner of the image.

The compact charging case provides an additional seven hours of playback.

In case you haven’t been keeping a tally at home, the Galaxy Buds Plus beat the Galaxy Buds, as they should: these are billed as an upgrade from the original headset and retail for $20 more than the Galaxy Buds did upon their debut. Today, you can get the Samsung Galaxy Buds for around $100 or less, making them an absolute steal. Pricing also happens to be the main reason as to why you should grab them over the Galaxy Buds Plus. You get 90% of what the Galaxy Buds Plus offer for ⅔ of the cost.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use the Samsung Galaxy Buds Plus and Galaxy Buds with an iPhone?

Yes, both the Samsung Galaxy Buds Plus and Samsung Galaxy Buds headsets can be used with an iPhone. In fact, iPhone users can enjoy high-quality wireless streaming with either the Galaxy Buds Plus or standard Galaxy Buds, thanks to AAC Bluetooth codec support. To pair with an iPhone, enable Bluetooth from your iPhone's settings menu. Open the charging case and keep it close to your iPhone; the Samsung Galaxy Buds Plus or Galaxy Buds will become available to pair with. Tap the desired device name from the Bluetooth menu.

Samsung Galaxy Buds Plus price?

The Samsung Galaxy Buds Plus price is subject to change but as of March 27, 2020, the Buds Plus cost $144 USD on Amazon, and the Samsung Galaxy Buds cost $99 USD on Amazon.