For the person who doesn’t want to think about their earphones while using them, Google has created the Pixel Buds A-Series. For a reasonable price, Google packs in a bevy of features like touch controls and a good fit into this Android-friendly set of earbuds to make productivity and life easier. However, one significant flaw might make you pause.
Editor’s note: this article was updated on September 13, 2021, to update about a firmware update and the Pixel Buds (2020) getting discontinued and to add the Jabra Elite 3 as an alternative.
Who’s the Google Pixel Buds A-Series for?
- Productivity-minded individuals will appreciate the intuitive integration of their buds with their Android device.
- Google Pixel fans will enjoy the aesthetic and clean integration with Android software at a reasonable price
What’s it like to use the Google Pixel Buds A-Series?
The Google Pixel Buds A-Series is cheerful in its execution, from the Tamagotchi-esque charging case to the lightweight earbuds with wings resembling bug antennae. This is probably the most achievable kind of aesthetic when working with a somewhat budget product. Clearly White is the color labeled on the box, but it’s not a pun on translucence. They’re opaque with a G on the housing where the touch controls reside. Dark Olive is the other colorway.
Start here: What makes a good set of in-ears?
The exterior of the Pixel Buds A-Series charging case is plastic, as are the earphones, with rubber hits where necessary. The rather flimsy lid doesn’t exactly inspire long-term confidence, but it hardly feels disposable. All told, it’s a pretty lightweight affair. In fact, it feels like Google has done you a favor by trimming excess weight, though I wouldn’t drop the case from great heights. The charging case has a USB-C connection, and I was surprised to discover it also has a magnet, meaning it’s not going to get yanked off your PC tower by the cable, and you can hang your niece’s artwork on the fridge with it. That’s pretty neat.
For a company whose mainstay is organizing information, the box and supplied guide provide very little information. I had to Google everything, including how to pair the earphones. Once connected though, these are some of the most comfortable earbuds I’ve ever worn. The Pixel Buds A-Series is light enough it sometimes feels like there’s nothing in my ears, and the earbuds’ pressure vents ensure long sessions don’t leave you with vertigo. The earbuds also come with small, medium, and large silicone ear tips, so you’ll have some leeway to figure out the right fit.
Equipped with an IPX4 rating, you can feel safe in the knowledge that you won’t destroy the A-Series during a sweaty workout. The buds can’t take a dip in the pool or officially resist dust, but this rating will save you from the occasional splash of water. The Google Pixel Buds A-Series does a little bit of everything, aiming to be your one main set of true wireless earphones at a budget price. It almost achieves this, but it’s just too quiet (more on that in a bit).
Adaptive sound is Google’s solution to noise cancellation
Adaptive Sound is available in the Pixel Buds app, and compensates for the auditory masking that occurs naturally while out in the world by—get this—using auditory masking. This is a practice we all do already: when you’re in a loud subway you turn your music up. These earphones do it for you, turning up the volume of your audio as your environment gets louder, and turning things down as it gets quieter. It’s also probably why the buds don’t have any tapping function to adjust the volume manually.
Other earphones use a combination of good isolation and active noise cancellation (ANC) to solve this problem, effectively reducing how much noise is competing with your ears. By contrast, Adaptive Sound competes with outside noise by being louder than it. I have a real love/hate relationship with its implementation.
For phone calls, Adaptive Sound works well. Since many of us aren’t making phone calls from ideal environments, an algorithm knowing to crank the volume in response to a noisy truck driving by is smart—it lets you stay focused on the conversation.
For music, I find Adaptive Sound distracting. It wrecks musical dynamics because it’s like turning the volume knob back and forth constantly. If a chorus of a song arrives just as I leave a loud construction zone, suddenly it’s going to sound disproportionately quiet. I find Adaptive Sound also turns on with a perceptible delay, which makes the decrease in volume all the more noticeable, so I leave it off most of the time.
Should you get the Pixel Buds app?
You don’t much of a choice in the matter: Google pretty much makes you download the Pixel Buds app (Android only). It automatically pops up when you pair the A-Series to your Android phone, and it’s one of the best aspects of these earphones. Seamless Android integration is one of the selling points of the Pixel Buds A-Series. You can track your earphones’ location, which is great for such a small item. The app lets you turn on Bass Boost, activate in-ear detection, and learn touch controls. It’s Google, so remember that it’s collecting data when you allow access to features like Find device, which basically GPS tracks your earphones.
Related: Best Google Assistant headphones
All of these features work as intended. The touch controls work effortlessly, though you can’t customize them. Google Assistant activates through voice commands, or by pressing and holding on the earbuds’ G logo. On an iPhone, your mileage may vary, much like with the pricier Pixel Buds, which uses the same app.
How does the Google Pixel Buds A-Series connect?
Open the case and press the back button to initiate pairing. You’ll know it’s in pairing mode because the case’s light will begin to flash alternately yellow and white. Select it from your device’s Bluetooth menu and it’s done. It connects easily, and stays connected using Bluetooth 5.0. During subsequent uses, it connects to my Android device with ease, maintains stability throughout.
Your Bluetooth codec options are AAC and SBC, which are okay, but nothing to write home about. The vast majority of people wouldn’t notice a difference between codec performance on the A-Series, particularly, if you’re streaming lossy audio anyhow.
How’s the battery on the Google Pixel Buds A-Series?
Google claims you get 5 hours of music playback and 2.5 hours of talk time. In use, a 90-minute phone call will leave the buds a little more than 50% charged. Our battery test yields 4 hours, 44 minutes with constant music playback at 75dB, landing in the realm of average for true wireless earphones.
The case can quick-charge the earbuds: 15 minutes in the case supplies the buds with 180 minutes of playback, or 90 minutes of talk time. Again, it charges via USB-C but doesn’t support wireless charging. For that, you’ll need the more premium Google Pixel Buds.
How does the Google Pixel Buds A-Series sound?
The Google Pixel Buds A-Series sounds quite good so long as your buds run firmware version 233 or later. Initially, the A-Series volume output was way too quiet before firmware version 233 (which we address in the next section).
Should you choose to try the earbuds, the A-Series has two frequency response options, one with Bass Boost off and one with it turned on. You don’t get any other EQ adjustments. Throughout the higher mids, the default setting does an okay job of following our house curve (seen in the pink line). The treble frequencies past 3kHz are a little wonky, while mids and bass below 400Hz are surprisingly quiet. If you could turn it up to an adequate volume, treble notes would sound too loud relative to the bass and mids.
I believe this default frequency curve isn’t for music—it’s for speech. Imagine wearing the Google Pixel Buds A-Series during a Zoom call. You want to hear people’s voices, and cut out the sibilance (those ear-piercing s sounds). Speech intelligibility doesn’t come from the bass region, so there’s no point having an especially audible low end. If anything, turning down the bass means de-emphasizing the sounds of folks loudly jostling in their desks during meetings.
Turning on the Bass Boost adds a bit more oomph to the audio. It adds a little more than the SoundGuys ideal, but this EQ is still much more suited to music than the other one. Due to the fairly neutral mids of the A-Series, I don’t find it too amplified or overly exaggerated, even with added bass.
Lows, mids, highs
With the default EQ, Free by SAULT sounds inaccurate on the A-Series. There is an overemphasis on the high mids and a one-dimensionality that results from not being able to hear any low end. With Bass Boost activated, suddenly I can hear the kick drum, the bass line, and some more emphasis to the pad synthesizer during the chorus. All of this is unfortunately undercut by the fact that these are just about the quietest earbuds I’ve ever tried. Even at max volume, the Google Pixel Buds A-Series is often too quiet with my phone. You’ll be constantly straining to hear things completely.
It’s clear isolation is not a priority of the A-Series, but then again, it never really was on any model of the pixel series. It seems as though the pressure vents might compromise the seal, and even more so than other earbuds with the same technology like the Samsung Galaxy Buds Pro or Sony WF-1000XM4. Since these earbuds never promised any real isolation, it’s not surprising there is very little. Google has designed the A-Series to keep you aware of your surroundings, rather than isolated from them.
How to fix the Google Pixel Buds A-Series volume issue
If your experience of the Google Pixel Buds A-Series is hampered by low volumes, you’re not alone: other users have cited the same OS-related issue with Android.
Google has released a firmware update to fix this issue (version 233). You can force a manual update, if your phone didn’t automatically initiate the update.
- Put your buds into the case.
- Open your Pixel Buds app.
- Tap More settings, then tap Firmware update.
- Hit Update available.
If Google hasn’t released the firmware update in your region there’s another way to fix the volume problem. To remedy this, you will need to access the Developer options on your phone. While this is a more involved process than most consumers seek out, it’s a rather simple (though convoluted) solution.
- Go to Settings
- Go to About phone
- Tap on where it says “Build number” seven times
- Tap the back arrow
- Go to System & updates
- Scroll down and select “Developer options”
- Enable the “Developer options”toggle
- Scroll down and enable the “Bluetooth absolute volume” toggle
Your earphones should immediately work at normal volume. If they don’t, restart your device.
How’s the microphone on the Google Pixel Buds A-Series?
Each earbud has two mics, and they pick up voices well. Voices come through sounding more or less like how they sound in real life, with a drop in overall resolution. The buds also do a good job of blocking out external noise. They do such a good job that sometimes they might mistake your voice for noise. In the demo, the A-Series manages to reject off-axis noise from a fan, but with the introduction of fan noise, it also cuts out part of the voice. In a quiet environment, this would not be an issue.
Should you buy the Google Pixel Buds A-Series?
Unfortunately, many of the issues we had with the previous two iterations of the Pixel Buds series are still unresolved with the new A-Series, and this wouldn’t be our first choice to recommend. However, if you’re deep into Google’s Android ecosystem, you won’t hate these earphones—you may just like other pairs better. These earbuds do offer some advantages over AirPods, though, especially when you consider that they isolate far better than the eponymous Apple earphones. Whether or not these are worth the money comes down to what you value in a set of earphones.
The connectivity is great and seamless. There’s integration for features like Google Assistant and finding your earbuds if they’re lost. The Google Pixel Buds A-Series is lightweight and comfortable, which makes it easy to wear for long periods. However, the difficulties we ran into alongside some performance tradeoffs are definitely things you should consider before buying.
What should you get instead?
If what appeals to you about the Google Pixel Buds A-Series is the easy integration with Android and Google Assistant, try the Samsung Galaxy Buds Plus. This runs around the same price, with frequency response tuned by AKG and multiple EQ presets. Unlike the A-Series, we never ran into any volume issues with the Galaxy Buds Plus. With a capable microphone, productivity is a breeze, too. You’ll have to upgrade to the Pro version or to the Samsung Galaxy Buds 2 if you want ANC, however.
Listeners who want a more affordable, more durable headset should look at the Jabra Elite 3. This pair of buds uses Bluetooth 5.2, supports aptX and SBC, and boasts an IP55 rating. While the lack of AAC support is sub-optimal for iPhone owners, this is a great set of basic earbuds for Android smartphone owners.
Keep in mind that Google seems intent on concentrating on the more budget-conscious Pixel Buds A-Series, as it recently discontinued the Google Pixel Buds (2020). Maybe you can find a set on sale.